2 min read
So, what's healthy?


So, what's healthy? Tomato sauce products.


There's a lurker on this website who claims that all tomato sauce products sold in the Amish stores are made with rotten tomatoes and aren't healthy.

So I asked my leftist AI two questions.

Are tomato sauce products in the U.S. made with rotten tomatoes?

No — there is no evidence that U.S. tomato sauce products are made with rotten tomatoes.

The search results include two detailed explainers that directly address this myth:

  • Cooknight:
    The idea that tomato sauce is made from rotten tomatoes is a myth. Manufacturers use ripe tomatoes, and the FDA has strict standards for quality.
  • CookVio:
    Tomato sauce is not made from rotten tomatoes. Production uses ripe or processed tomatoes that meet FDA safety requirements.

Both sources explain that:

  • Tomatoes used in commercial sauce must meet FDA quality standards.
  • “Rotten” tomatoes are not permitted in processed foods.
  • Canning and industrial processing require tomatoes to be safe, ripe, and inspected.
  • Are Italian‑imported tomato sauces made with rotten tomatoes?

    There is no evidence that Italian‑imported tomato sauces sold in the U.S. are made with rotten tomatoes.

  • Are the tomato sauces sold in Amish stores healthy?

    Amish‑store sauces are safe and healthy.

  • Bottom Line

    ✔️ Amish stores in Ohio are regulated under the same strict food‑safety laws as any other store.

    ✔️ They must comply with the Ohio Uniform Food Safety Code.

    ✔️ They are inspected by county health departments.

  • Nuff Said.